I am very relieved to read your eye is okay. Because their products do not cost a great deal, they do not offer returns, exchanges, or refunds once they have shipped an order. If irritation occurs, consult your ophthalmologist. In 2016, a kit of Pigments and Glitters had this warning for the Glitter and Reflects Glitter: Not for use in the eye area, though the Reflects line of Glitters contains calcium sodium borosilicate (not plastic glitter; other Glitters in the range do contain plastic glitter) and +/- color additives, while two Pigments included in the same kit also contain this ingredient but included additional ingredients beyond color additives. After the surgery I was prescribed the same eye drops for another 3 months. I got my item quick and easy since it was my first-time ordering form Colourpop. 3 years ago. Aside from the health concerns, its kind of odd to me that microbeads have become verboten but PET based glitters remain popular. I am really hoping the PET plastic-in-eyeshadow trend dies soon. Im so glad you didnt have permanent damage from this experience. 4,844 likes, 156 comments - Rose Siard (@roseandben) on Instagram: "I did a #bridalmakeup look today on my story!! contact us! Is polyester glitter safer than PET glitter? Zinc Stearate is also one of the ingredients in this product, and it gives good adherence, as it helps the powders in this product stick together and to your skin on application. Amazon.com: Colourpop Lip Liner . That means no lipstick, blush, lip liner, or general color product should ever go near your eyes. Cosmetic-grade glitter is typically made out of plastic, cut differently, and while largely self-regulated by the brands that release the products, are intended for cosmetics use (at least on face and body). Awesomely comprehensive research and thanks for your personal input. Im sorry about your experience but am glad that there was no permanent damage. Lips. I love the bronzer and very much enjoy the Posh lipstick and lip liner. But yes, every time I go back in the winter, my poor already dry eyes are so dry. These matte shades have the best formula! 2023 Trustpilot, Inc. All rights reserved. Dry skin. Craft glitter can be cut from glass, metal, and may be coated in dyes that are not suitable for cosmetic use. Alternative ingredients need to be used. They don't test finished products or ingredients on animals, and neither do their suppliers or any third-parties. In 2009, MAC glitters came with this warning: Keep entirely clear of eye area. The Foundation Matrix is designed to help. Excellent article Christine, thank you for all your hard work and the hours you invested!! Yesterday I had a thought when I was struggling to find a hot-pink eyeliner: Could I just use a lip liner on my eyes? These are still non-permitted color additives in eye-area use cosmetics. Good luck. COLOURPOP EYESHADOW QUESTION I recently discovered a new online American cosmetic company, Colourpop I was shopping on their website and noticed several products that are sold with their eyeshadows and liners that have the disclaimer not for use around the eyes. It looks like Colourpop is using red lakes that are not FDA approved for use around the eyes. I just ordered blue contacts after 20 years of not playing with them and it was some youtubers suggestion (with code) I got them in, but they felt like they were too convaved and stood out too much on the inside of my eyelid. Also, Urban Decay Moondust shadows are in the same category of risk when worn on the eye as say MAC glitter? Anyone who is vegan (or indeed anyone) might want to consider that. Tell us your current shade match, and we'll help you find a match in your next foundation or concealer! Those who still want to risk glitter, Id like to plug Eco Stardust (https://ecostardust.com/pages/non-bioglitter-amnesty) You can send them your plastic glitter to recycle and you can get a discount on their actually biodegradable glitter. Companies generally do not care about your safety. As such, you will not develop dry skin, acne, or rash when you use ColourPop products because they are free of toxic and dangerous chemicals. Perhaps the key with the fluorphlogopite is that the shadow be very well put together, meaning not having any fallout. Light Plus, Neutral undertones. There are some derivatives like polybutylene, but it likely will have terephthalate with it. Service 61. The cream eyeshadow will work perfectly on the inner corner or even along the lashline. It is more important to notify the FDA of a reaction than the brand as brands are not required to report back to the FDA. The more uniform edge, as opposed to natural mica, seems to be why brands feel comfortable using larger particle-sized synthetic mica than natural mica. IDK if products with that ingredient are made with less of a fine powder, or if there are chunkier ones available too. I think its one thing for a brand to sell individual pressed or loose glitter as a standalone product, but when a brand includes them in a premade eyeshadow palette, it seems like theyre endorsing their consumers to use the glitter on their eyes, even if theres language on the box warning against it not being intended for that use. There are some of U.S. cosmetics are actually banned in other countries due to their ingredients, like formaldehyde. That product is in a lot fewer shadows and Im pretty sure that the colors that have them are the ones that bother my eyes if theres any fallout. My personal takeaway from my recent experience and after sifting through what little information was available is to use caution when working with products near or around the eyes, particularly when working with larger particles, whether more traditional sparkle or glitter, and when working with mascara wands (Ive poked myself in the eye at least a dozen times over the years) and brushes (keep em clean!). If. The answer is pretty shocking. "You need to be careful around eyes; take no chances. The U.S. more or less expects cosmetic companies to self regulate. You mentioned some regulations and Im sure you didnt find much. there are things like mica, but that isn't glitter. The only way to increase safety standards (physical safety and environmental safety) is to make a lot of noise about it. I guess Ive been living under a rock because Im 43 and just discovered them. In terms of colors, a nude lip liner in a neutral hue close to the natural shade of your lips is good to have on hand, while a lip liner in brown gives you that nostalgic '90s look. Hyaluronic acid can also help lessen the redness and visible appearance of acne and protect your skin, which is helpful for acne-prone skin. Is there any danger in doing this? -24C thats without the windchill. I like that they let me know about my order; I really appreciate the use of DHL. Which 3 brands would you rebuild your entire makeup collection - Reddit While doing our ColourPop review, we checked some of the products they offer to see how safe they are, the ingredients they use to create them, and who should use them. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Love all the products. ColourPop Over the Liner Lippie Pencil Review & Swatches Outstanding piece, Christine. answered already. https://www.fatherly.com/news/glitter-is-destroying-the-environment-scientists-ban/. Your California Privacy Rights. Can ColourPop lip products be used on eyelids? : MakeupAddiction - Reddit It seemed innocuous enough. ColourPop Pencil Lip Makeup for sale | eBay On the other hand, the soft blurring pigment technology provides a flawless complexion that lasts throughout the day. Very systematic, referring to precedents, etc. This is where I stood a week ago, and Im really in the same place nowI dont feel like I have that much more information. Of all the things we are exposed to over the course of our lives Im sure a few specks of glitter are the least of my worries, but I do sometimes think about it, especially with the glitters that are specifically designed to break down. We've done a little digging about the newest trend, so that you don't have to. I might be allergic to ColourPop products! The follow-up question is also what is the definition of safe because CIR says ocular injury is not likely but does, ultimately, say PET glitter is safe to use in eye cosmetics, so it seems safe is more of a spectrum of safety not that it is 100% safe. will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed). Though these eyeliners cost just $7 a tube, ColourPop's creamy consistency rivals even the most high-end eyeliners. Apply tape (if its very sticky, remove a bit of the stickiness on the back of your hand) with light pressure on the glittery area and remove, and start again with fresh tape, and go on for as long as youve removed as much as you can. Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches! There are alternatives to using plastic glitter, like synthetic fluorophlogopite (which is lab-made mica) and borosilicates, which are two ways Lush replaced plastic glitter in their products, that have widespread usage in cosmetics already. is a light-medium, reddish-plum with warmer undertones and a matte finish. Are they really dry? Not to worry -- we can still help! Can You Really Use Lip Liner as Eyeliner? | Allure This list is useful in particular for anyone who is concerned about Pressed Pigments (not glitter) as you can look up the various pigments used in a particular shade to see if it is approved for eye usage or not. Then soak my lashes with an additional cotton pad to get rid of the mascara. Our ColourPop tinted moisturizer review discovered that you need to prepare your skin with a hyaluronic hydrating primer if you want extra hydration. "Colors intended for use around the eye have to be specially approved by the FDA.". A few customers did not like that ColourPop does not offer refunds and returns. For comparison, Lit Cosmetics sells three sizes of loose glitter where Size #2 is dubbed small at 0.004 x 0.004 or 101.6 m x 101.6 m, Size #3 is medium at 0.008 x 0.008 or 203.2 x 203.2 m, and Size #4 is large at 0.015 x 0.015 or 381 x 381 m (note: Ive made assumptions that Lits measurements are in inches before converting to microns). I tried eye drops just to see if maybe my eyes were dry or something and they just felt odd. While every cosmetics brand would love to get positive reviews, they all have several negative reviews from unsatisfied customers. Borosilicate pigments like the Mermaid colors are uniquely reflective. If a makeup artist is using craft glitter they need to be corrected immediately. As for the very small ones in PMG Bronze Blaze, I havent had any serious issues.yet. More liquid lipsticks you'll love: This Pinterest-Favorite Lipstick . Our ColourPop review found that the company offers international shipping, but orders are subject to duty fees and customs as defined by your country. If you have general feedback, I need information please. Ginger King, a cosmetic chemist is completely against using lip products around your eyes, per Allure. The lip stains (bought cherry pop and another deep color) have absolutely no pigment and look like nudes on my light olive tone skin. Eyelashes. Lippie Pencil - ColourPop | Ulta Beauty Thanks, Christina! I love Colourpop eyeshadow palettes, and eye makeup! You can find a list of FDA-approved Color Additives here, which will also breakdown restrictions on use or any limitations. Youre an absolute pearl. My products have not yet arrived at my house and I have waited more than 20 days. Very Light, Yellow, slight yellow undertones. Gel . Thank you! That means you do not have to break the bank to enhance your appearance and boost your self-esteem using their products. Verification can help ensure real people write reviews about real companies. Moreover, the product has dimethicone, which prevents shine by absorbing excess sweat on your skin to keep the bronzer looking pristine. They are my favorite posts on temptalia. from. No Filter ColourPop Concealer features Cyclopentasiloxane, a silicone that evaporates quickly and makes the concealer dry fast. Its inexpensive but very high quality which means I can and do buy everything I want! I really enjoy their makeup; the colors are great, the packaging is adorable, the quality is good, and the price is very reasonable. The Fenty Rose (4) and Smoky (6) eyeshadow palettes both contain glitter shades, which have PET glitter in them, but they are listed as eyeshadows with an eye icon on the back of the palette with no disclosure or warning on either the cardboard packaging or the actual palette that I could find. Im a senior and although this product is marketed toward younger customers, it works very well for me. We pride ourselves on being 100% cruelty-free, wallet-friendly and keeping our community at the center of our world. Cruelty Free Create clean lines and prevent feathering disasters with ColourPop's long-wearing and super pigmented Lippie Pencil liner, designed to be worn under your fave matching lip color. Unfortunately, the yellow liner is incredibly streaky. Combination skin. Eyebrows. Thank you for sharing this experience. Would you please be able to weigh in with your thoughts always love your insight and analysis of these topics! They need to get their sh*t together on this one before people end up with serious damage to their corneas! Products like Stilas Glitter & Glow Liquid Eyeshadows contain plastic glitter in several shades and classic Urban Decay Eyeshadows (seems like most that were described as having micro-glitter) like Chopper, Gunmetal, and Midnight Cowboy (not an exhaustive list) also used PET glitter. Register. Glitter eye makeup is a common cause of corneal irritation or infection, especially for people who wear contact lenses. Only a sensation of grittiness if any fallout gets in my eye when I use that shade or the similarly textured Gilty Pleasure. Dear Christine, thank you so much for this. You can also buy their products at one of the ColourPop store locations because they have tons of physical shops throughout the country, including California, Alabama, Arizona, Colorado, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, New York, and other states. Synthetic fluorphlogopite is supposed to have a more uniform finish which does not contain any sharp edges (per Lush). Lip Stain. Everyone should have a good grasp of the general dos and donts of what to do if something gets in your eye, and if youre someone who regularly wears eye makeup, particularly anything with larger particles (like glitter), Id say its well-worth knowing what to do (or not do) before you need to know it! Normal-to-Dry skin. Clionadh cosmetics has some beautifully unique shadows and uses Bioglitter too. Also, I hope youre healing well. I enjoyed the read, even though you didnt really get any clear answers than what youve already been told or suspected. I also realize that a lot of things can cause damage to the eye, even if technically safe, whether thats makeup or you know dust or sand! Is Colourpop Cruelty-Free? | 2022 Cruelty-Free Kitty Update Just be smart: Don't then go back and start wiping the contaminated pencil on your eyes (ewwww). Lipstick. The eyeliner has a cartridge of .55-ml ink encased in a stylish pen and contains butylene glycol to make the other ingredients spread out in their desired form for use. And Christine, thank you for this article. hydrating, plumping lip gloss with the ultimate glassy finish , Swipe on to hydrate lips with a crystal clear sheen! Hey Christine! Im not sure what the difference is they both seem bad for the environment. Also regarding Lasik. When you make a purchase through links on this page, we may earn a commission. I will never, ever order from colourpop ever again if customer service is that terrible. Its not both. Are you new to the world of foundation or have you never felt like you've found an ideal shade match? You can then subscribe to their newsletter to get updated whenever there is a new deal on your favorite products. Turns out you should never, ever use a lip liner as an eyeliner. I always read the ingredients in everything before I purchase, and the 1st time I ever saw fluorphlogopite as an ingredient was when Hourglass came out with their Ambient Lighting products. I think your post will start a much needed revolution in the industry, with regards to Glitter. I think pressed glitter should be sold at least separately, if brand wants to include that in their range. In terms of ingredients, theyre using plastic (PET) glitter as well, so theirs doesnt appear different than other uses by makeup brands like UD, MAC, etc. I ordered a FULL Mandalorian set. I fangirl when I see you turning on law school mode. Highly pigmented super bendable powders in many beautiful colors. (If youre so inclined, you can click here to review the FDAs color additive list for yourself.). Wherever I go, He goes ColourPop Eyeshadow makes your eyes stand and look more attractive by adding depth and dimension to your eyes, complementing your eye color, and making your eyes appear larger. Youll primarily be looking for this ingredient: polyethylene terephthalate. What happens if you use lip liner as eyeliner? I have worn glitter products for years, too, on the lid as well as below the lash line (not the waterline) not always fully aware of the risks but quite aware of potential risks in the last few years. PET is a polyester resin (so a type of polyester) which is probably why it was referred to this way. LOL! So a humidifier on my desk and constant eye drops and my eyes were finally moist enough to do the surgery again. Thats what kind of scared me the most about it. I hope youre feeling better now! Dry skin. This is fascinating to me (although Im sorry you had to go through this). The quality of the makeup is fantastic!I'm so impressed with the color options and the overall visual beauty of the products. We know by the types of products released that PET glitter comes in an array of sizes and shapes, and it doesnt seem illogical that size and shape might increase or decrease potential for ocular irritation or injury, but theres no information that Im aware of on that. In addition to refreshing your tired-looking eyes, No Filter ColourPop Concealer masks large pores, age spots, camouflage dark circles, and other blemishes visible on your skin with just one swipe. The items are available in limited quantities, and you cannot replace them with other products or credit. , An emerald green to gold to tealmulti chrome finish, A vibrant cobalt blue to purple duo chrome finish , A deep blue to teal to purplemulti chrome finish, An opalescent gold to pink to copper multi chrome finish, A vibrant pink to peach to goldmulti chrome finish , A metallic sage to terracotta duo chrome finish , A bright magenta to rich purple to bronzemulti chrome finish. It seems like it would be more responsible not to include it in the palette at all. and I had to pay custom fees over the price of the products without the discountplus, it was missing an item. Find your next foundation or concealer match! (Please refer to first mention of CIR for potential conflict of interest information.) Ill just read what their website says, then well look at the ingredients, and then review the FDAs regulation on colorants for cosmetics. In my quest to try and to provide information to readers, I considered looking to ophthalmologists, who would likely be the ones seeing the impacts of glitter. , As an eye care professional, I would like to say thank you from my heart for this! So I wanted to get a status update on glitter in eye cosmetics. Thank you for posting about it and Im glad youre okay. Colourpop never fails to come out with amazing new palettes and products. In part of its findings, CIR wrote that a lack of case reports and no ongoing FDA regulatory actions suggested to the Panel that ocular injury is not likely. If, in fact, consumers sustain ocular injury from the use of PET glitter, then it seems it will fall to consumers to report those injuries to the FDA. FDA considers glitter and mica-based composite pigments to be non-permitted color additives when used in FDA-regulated products, including cosmetics. They have a few authorized sellers, which can be found on colourpop.com. Both borosilicates and synthetic mica are pretty common from what Ive seen, so Id definitely pay attention to what shades have given you trouble, but Id pay particular attention to see if theres any correlation with type of formula or particle size like a lot of people love how sparkly some Pat McGrath shades are, but they definitely have more visible sparkle to them and theres a range of sizes for both types of ingredients. contact us directly. . The 100%-vegan-and-cruelty-free formula consists of marine ingredients that hydrate and protect your delicate under eyes. However, you can cancel your order before shipping by reaching out to the customer support team. It doesnt apply to every shade from Pat McGrath, but they have used it before! I obviously wanted it. No doubt, the day is coming when someone out there does suffer permanent eye injury due to using a PET glitter eyeshadow. 1 of 3. By entering your email address you will receive promotional updates. Long time reader now subscribed. is a light-medium, reddish-plum with warmer undertones and a matte finish. That means no lipstick, blush, lip liner, or general color product should ever go near your eyes. Contacted customer service and they would not send it to me even though it was in stock and available and after repeating myself countless times asking why I was unable to get the pallet I gave up. Having had a nasty little experience with Marc Jacobs Topaz Flash myself, I totally sympathize with you over your own experience with Fenty Rose Palette. Light Plus, Neutral, slight yellow undertones. . Rose Siard on Instagram: "I did a #bridalmakeup look today on my story Too firm and it won't lay down enough pigment and will be drying to the lips. I was very happy with the smooth order experience, fast shipping, and careful packaging of items in glass bottles to prevent breakage. The FDAs response, received on January 16th, 2020: FDA regulates the dyes and pigments used for coloring foods, drugs, cosmetics, and medical devices or the human body as color additives. Glitter (polyethylene terephthalate) imparts color to cosmetics so it meets the definition of a color additive. Which is why Im so pleased that Christine put this post out. The own thing that I wonder about is that if an eyeshadow palette is being sold with a color that states not to be used on the eye due to the glitter, what in the world do they expect you to use it for? Hopefully word will spread further with it over time. ColourPop Ultra Blotted Lip: Everything You Need to Know About - Allure I want to recommend a tip to anyone and everyone that use glitter, no matter what type or size it is: Remove it with tape. Is It Safe To Use Lip Liner On Your Eyes? - TheList.com We pride ourselves on being cruelty-free, wallet-friendly, and keeping our customers at the center of our world. Thank you for understanding! As a dry eye suffer who constantly has scratches on her cornea because theyre so dry (made worse from Lasik back then), the last thing I want are more scratches on my eyes. I've made multiple purchases with Colourpop and have been happy so far. Light, Pink, moderately pink undertones. I wore both glitter eyeshadows on part of lower lash linesnot my waterlines but below my eyelineras past personal experience has given me more irritation from glitter fallout into my eyes (often requiring early removal of a look) when Ive worn it on my lid (I had no irritation during wear, only after removal). I think brands should just not use plastic glitter or any other kind there are so many other, much safer finishes to use. I actually think the push toward being more eco-friendly here might be the way PET glitter gets phased out over time. Thank you for your patience! Colourpop Ultra Matte Lip Photos, Review, Swatches We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get However, it became a bigger issue when I discovered that Im allergic to synthetic mica.